League table
Top pizza restaurants in New York City
Ordered by star rating and how many reviews back it up, the same way for everyone. How the table works
- Places
- 10
- Reviews counted
- 36,844
- Position 1
Reviews: 459
Rating: 4.9
Points: 4.87
- Position 2
Reviews: 1,912
Rating: 4.8
Points: 4.79
- Position 3
Rosetta Pizza & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 172 reviews
Reviews: 172
Rating: 4.8
Points: 4.73
- Position 4
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 1,988 reviews
Reviews: 1,988
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.69
- Position 5
Roma Pizza & restaurant
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 1,680 reviews
Reviews: 1,680
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.69
- Position 6
ANDIAMO PIZZA
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 1,678 reviews
Reviews: 1,678
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.69
- Position 7
Reviews: 908
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.69
- Position 8
SIMÒ PIZZA - MIDTOWN
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 610 reviews
Reviews: 610
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.68
- Position 9
Madison Pizza NYC
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 240 reviews
Reviews: 240
Rating: 4.7
Points: 4.65
- Position 10
Joe's Pizza Broadway
Pizza restaurant · New York City · 27,197 reviews
Reviews: 27,197
Rating: 4.4
Points: 4.40
P: reviews counted · Rtg: average stars · Pts: rating weighed by reviews · How the table works
Pizza restaurants in New York City
Good to know
Which pizza restaurants in New York City top the table?
Weighing each rating by its number of reviews, the top spots go to Pop’s Pizza - Times Square (4.9★, 459 reviews), Pop's Pizza (4.8★, 1,912 reviews) and Rosetta Pizza & Restaurant (4.8★, 172 reviews).
How many pizza restaurants does TopRatedLocals rank in New York City?
There are 10 pizza restaurants in this table.
Can I find pizza restaurants in New York City open on a Sunday?
Yes: 10 of the 10 with listed hours open on Sundays, for example Pop’s Pizza - Times Square (10 AM–12 AM), Pop's Pizza (11 AM–11 PM) and Rosetta Pizza & Restaurant (9 AM–2 AM). Hours can change, so a quick call first is a good idea.
Which pizza restaurants in New York City have the most reviews?
Joe's Pizza Broadway (27,197 reviews), Quality Pizza Co. Midtown (1,988 reviews) and Pop's Pizza (1,912 reviews).